QUARTERLY LETTER
Published Fourth Quarter 1998
Muhlenkamp
Memorandum 48
The Third Quarter of 1998 was brutal. So
far this year, U. S. economic fundamentals, (Gross Domestic
Product growth, inflation, and interest rates) have matched
our expectations. Despite this, the market's actions over
the past three months have focused on investors' fears and,
at times, have approached a self-feeding panic. We think it
is way overdone.
Since April, there have been three down
legs in the equity markets. The first one we expected. It
was simply a 10% correction.
The second leg occurred when several pieces
of bad news hit at the same time. Clinton's testimony before
the grand jury shouldn't have surprised anyone, but it may
have produced a negative effect, particularly on foreign investors.
The terrorist attacks against the United States were a surprise,
but only in a narrow sense. The third part was Russia imploding
and defaulting on its debts. Again, this didn't surprise us;
we had been expecting it for years. But Russia's problems
commanded headlines and an emotional response out of proportion
to their economic impact. Maybe it's because most of us were
raised on a fear of Russia. At any rate, all this news hitting
in a short period of time caused stocks to decline and continue
to decline as momentum players kept selling.
The third down leg occurred more recently
when a sizeable hedge fund, with blue-chip people running
it, flirted with bankruptcy. That surprised a lot of people,
including us. It also rattled the financial markets. The banks
that loaned the hedge fund money bailed it out instead of
letting it go bankrupt. Since then, the banks are enforcing
their margin calls on other hedge funds (there are a lot of
hedge funds) forcing them to sell securities. Some people
who are in a position to monitor these funds expect half of
them to go out of business. Bank loans to hedge funds are
short-term loans; they don't have 20 or 30 years to pay them
back. So margin calls result in immediate sales, regardless
of price.
This results in continued momentum selling
by professionals, and panic selling by the public. Many people
are selling for emotional, not economic, reasons. In some
cases, they know it's a mistake but can't stand the pain.
Again, they're selling regardless of price.
Where are we today?
There are two main questions yet to be answered:
- Is there another big surprise that could
hit the markets?
Yes, always.
- Having changed their investing patterns;
will people change their spending patterns?
Changes in spending affect the economy. We saw it happen
in 1990 with the Gulf War. However, it did not happen in
1987 or 1994 when we had market declines without economic
declines. At this point, the economy is still doing well.
Six months ago, the Fed wanted a slow-down in the economy.
Today, investors fear a slow-down in the economy. The only
difference between six months ago and today is that stock
prices are down. The jury is still out as to whether a decline
in the stock market will drive a decline in the economy.
In the past
month, we heard from Dr. Milton Friedman and Dr. James Tobin,
both Nobel Prize winning economists. Milton Friedman probably
knows more about the Great Depression than anybody living
today. Dr. Tobin was an economist for the Kennedy administration.
Dr. Friedman said that the odds of a worldwide economic depression
are trivial, while Dr. Tobin said the odds are quite small.
We believe that problems and perceptions have to get pretty
bad for governments to change. You have to go through a certain
amount of pain just to get government attention. But national
governments are beginning to respond. Japan has just passed
meaningful legislation and our federal government has now
lowered interest rates by a quarter of a point, twice. Both
are responding to the slow-down instead of worrying about
inflation (the reverse of three months ago). We believe there
has been enough pain inflicted, and it has scared enough people
that further actions will be taken by government bodies. Unless
an additional major problem hits the fan, it is a great time
to invest. We still have 10-20% of our assets in cash and
Treasury bonds. We are starting to put that money back to
work in stocks, because we are seeing some great companies
at very cheap prices. We do believe that there will be continued
selling through the end of the year for tax-loss purposes.
We don't think we have to be in a big hurry, but it is a time
to do our homework and prepare to buy the values we see.
If you wonder about the wisdom of what we
are doing, or have trouble sleeping at night, we suggest that
you take a close look at the companies whose stock we own.
Think of them as businesses, not pieces of paper; review their
balance sheets, their income statements, and their cash flow
statements, then determine whether you're comfortable investing
in these companies at the current prices. And remember that
our money is invested in these companies right along with
yours.
Read our quarterly newsletter, Muhlenkamp
Memorandum, for more by Ron Muhlenkamp.
|